My girlfriend always admitted that she likes big cocks but whenever I asked her if she liked the big toys I used on her better than my cock she always insisted that my cock was the best. I never knew what to believe so I finally tried an experiment: I told her that from now on I would only fuck her while wearing the sleeve you see in the picture (9×8). I told her it had nothing to do with her pleasure and I was going to do it solely because it turned me on to stretch her out.
I should have know what was going to happen when she didn’t even argue with my plan. And sure enough, it only took a few times of fucking her with the sleeve before she dropped all the BS and finally told me the truth about how she really felt. I had already been fucking her for a few minutes and she had already cum twice when suddenly the floodgates opened: “Baby, were you serious that you will always wear the sleeve now? Because…please don’t be mad…but it feels so much better than your cock. It’s so much bigger and I cum so much harder. This is the size my pussy needs. Your cock is really nice but this is so much bigger and it feels so much better. This is the only way I want you to fuck me anymore. Please don’t be mad. This was your idea, I can’t help that it feels so good.” I told her don’t worry and just enjoy it.
I think afterwards she felt bad about it and tried taking back some of the things she had said during sex but once I reassured her that I wasn’t upset, she admitted that everything she had said was true and that she wants it all the time now. It has been two weeks now of wearing the sleeve every time during sex and she has gotten much more comfortable (braver?) and now routinely tells me that my cock is small and that even when wearing the sleeve it only feels like a “standard cock” now. When I suggested getting a thicker sleeve she said that if she gets used to an even bigger sleeve, she will probably never be able to cum on just my cock anymore. But if I’m ok with that, then she would like a bigger sleeve so she can have that stretched feeling again. I’m not sure what to do now.